Studs • Hoops • Drops • Designer premiums
Sell Diamond Earrings in Northbrook, IL
Earrings come in many styles, so pricing can vary more than most sellers expect. Still, when you work with a local diamond buyer, you can quickly learn what drives the offer and what does not. The key is to understand whether the value sits in one larger diamond per ear, or in a group of smaller stones spread across the design.
Which earrings usually bring the strongest offers?
First, larger round stud earrings tend to be the most valuable because they resell easily. Next, well-matched pairs with good color and clarity typically perform better than mismatched stones. However, premium designer earrings can also do very well, even when the diamonds are smaller, because buyers pay for brand desirability.
- Top demand: larger round diamond studs (one stone per ear)
- Strong second tier: matched fancy shapes (princess, oval, pear, emerald cut)
- Style-driven: fine drops, hoops, or clusters (value depends on total diamond quality)
Additionally, antique platinum filigree earrings can command a premium when the work is clean and intact. That’s because collectors and buyers often seek that exact craftsmanship.
How we estimate your earring value
To begin, we separate the pricing into two parts: the diamonds and the setting. Next, we look at how the stones are arranged. If the pair uses many small diamonds, wholesale pricing often runs lower per carat than a pair of larger center stones. Therefore, “total carat weight” alone can be misleading.
Send these details for a faster estimate
- Front photo and side photo of both earrings
- Total carat weight if you know it (or any paperwork)
- Brand name if stamped (Tiffany & Co., Cartier, and more)
- Any missing backs or damaged parts
Quick check: If you have studs, tell us whether the diamonds are screw-back or push-back. That detail can hint at the quality level and the original retail category.
Private selling, clear decisions
Because we meet by appointment, you get a calm, one-on-one evaluation. After we confirm the details, we provide a direct offer and you decide what you want to do. If you accept, we handle payment promptly. If you decline, you keep your earrings—simple and respectful.
Local or mail-in
We’re based in Northbrook, so local sellers can meet in person. Meanwhile, out-of-state sellers can ask about insured shipping after the initial estimate. Either way, you get the same clear evaluation and the same straightforward communication.
Designer earrings and premium brands
Designer jewelry often holds value better because buyers recognize the name and trust the manufacturing quality. For that reason, we ask about brand marks early in the conversation. If you see a signature stamp, a serial number, or original packaging, share a photo of it. Then, we can estimate the “brand premium” more accurately.
We frequently evaluate brands such as Breitling, Bvlgari, Cartier, Chanel, Chopard, David Webb, David Yurman, Fope, as well as Fred Paris, Georg Jensen, Graff, Hermès, Ilias Lalaounis, Ippolita, John Hardy, Lagos. In addition, we buy pieces from many other makers, so don’t hesitate to ask even if your brand isn’t listed.
Before you meet: keep it simple
Finally, avoid harsh cleaners and aggressive polishing before the appointment. A gentle wipe with a soft cloth is enough. That way, we can inspect the stones and metal without residue, and you avoid accidental damage.